Diablo 4 bags multiple perfect review scores—here’s what critics are saying about Blizzard’s ‘return to darkness’
Despite live service misgivings, some are calling Diablo 4 the best Diablo yet.
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
Diablo 4will be out this week for pre-orderers, but between the betas and early review access, we’ve already completed the six-act campaign and have published our in-progressDiablo 4 review.
The short version of our take is that it’s fun, but the MMO-like live service structure stretches the joy of clicking on skeletons for loot in uncomfortable directions. That’s not an uncommon opinion among other reviewers, but for several publications, Diablo 4 is a masterpiece, live service features or not.
We’re going to dig into the live version of Diablo 4 before we score it with our final review, but a number of other outlets have already stamped verdicts on the action RPG, and several have given it their highest review honors.
One of our sibling sites,Windows Central, awarded Diablo 4 five-out-of-five stars, saying that it may be Blizzard’s best game yet. Our friends atTRGalso dropped a perfect score, as didPCGamesN,VideoGamer, and a handful of other outlets.
The lowest Diablo 4 scores so far are in the 70s, which isn’t very low at all. Here’s a selection of reviews that cover the current spectrum:
The reviews praise Diablo 4’s gorier art style, its story (“far more engrossing” than previous Diablos, said GameSpot), and combat design.
“I cannot overstate just how satisfying it is to play Diablo 4 on a moment-to-moment basis,” wroteTwinfinite, “and with so much replay value to be had from its various classes and build possibilities within those classes, Diablo 4 feels like a true return to form for the series,”
The biggest gaming news, reviews and hardware deals
Keep up to date with the most important stories and the best deals, as picked by the PC Gamer team.
Ourin-progress reviewis among the more critical at the moment: Tyler Colp writes that “by reconfiguring its entire structure around what used to be relegated to the endgame,” Diablo 4 loses much of what appealed to him about the series. Other reviews also point out friction between Diablo’s best qualities and the live service structure, though. In its unscored, positive review,Polygon expresses"mixed feelings" over the “MMO-ification of Sanctuary,” for example.
One caveat to these reviews: thebattle passand real-money cosmetics shop were not live during the pre-release review period. Reviewers did see a video of the features, though, and that was another focus of the live service-related criticism. Destructoid, for instance, found the shop’s placement in an in-game menu unseemly.
“If we’re treating the game like an MMORPG, I can allow some leeway for cosmetic microtransactions,“Destructoidwrites. “However, the avenue to purchase them has no business within the core gameplay loop of a $70-$100 game. Not only is this immersion breaking, but it also subtly inflicts a psychological temptation that builds over hours of playing and seeing that ‘SHOP’ tab stare you in the face.”
That complaint didn’t hold Destructoid back from awarding Diablo 4 an 8/10, and that’s representative of the overall landscape of Diablo 4 opinions so far: Fun game, even where the modern live service features may be detrimental. It’s reminiscent of Diablo 3’s reception: That game futzed around with 2012’s hottest new games-as-a-service ideas, with its unpopular always-online requirement and real-money auction house, but was alsoa critical successat the time, despite now being seen as a black sheep in the series. (Diablo 3 improved a lot over the years, though, and is a great game if you ask me.)
We’ll publish our final review after we’ve spent more time in Diablo 4’s live environment—here again isour review-in-progresswith our preliminary judgments.
Tyler grew up in Silicon Valley during the ’80s and ’90s, playing games like Zork and Arkanoid on early PCs. He was later captivated by Myst, SimCity, Civilization, Command & Conquer, all the shooters they call “boomer shooters” now, and PS1 classic Bushido Blade (that’s right: he had Bleem!). Tyler joined PC Gamer in 2011, and today he’s focused on the site’s news coverage. His hobbies include amateur boxing and adding to his 1,200-plus hours in Rocket League.
FF14 is finally fixing the fact my carefully-constructed portraits keep reverting to a goddamn driver’s licence photo whenever I change my goddamn gear
Dragon Age: The Veilguard’s first patch adds some Mass Effect flair to your wardrobe
Vampire Survivors’ Castlevania DLC map is so big that I keep getting lost, but I’d do it all over again just to have Sonia Belmont’s sonic whip
